Thank you for your patience. Your civilization is very important to us.
Thank you for your patience. Your civilization is very important to us.
“Grade every policy A–F by what actually happened”
— Wishonia, Planetary Systems Engineer
Throughput of a process that takes 2-4 months per bill. By the time it's scored, the political moment has passed.
The CBO is 'nonpartisan' in the same way a referee is neutral — everyone screams at them and the rules keep changing.
CBO deficit projections are routinely off by hundreds of billions. The 10-year forecast is astrology with spreadsheets.
Every policy graded by what actually happened when someone tried it. Cross-country causal inference, not projection.
Weighted by study rigor, precision, and recency. Shows its work. Can't be lobbied.
200ms, not 4 months. The algorithm doesn't need to convene a meeting.
CBO staff scoring legislation and economic forecasts
Cost to operate the Congressional Budget Office
How long it takes to produce a cost estimate for one piece of legislation
Elected officials routinely pressure CBO for favorable scores
275 analysts × 4 months → 1 function call
// budgetImpactScore() — replaces CBO scoring
export function calculateWES(estimates: EffectEstimate[]): WESCalculationResult {
let totalWeightedScore = 0;
for (const est of estimates) {
const wQ = qualityWeight(est.method); // How rigorous was the study?
const wP = precisionWeight(est.se); // How precise is the estimate?
const wR = recencyWeight(est.year); // How recent is the evidence?
totalWeightedScore += wQ * wP * wR; // Combine all three
}
const score = Math.min(1, totalWeightedScore / K); // Normalize to 0-1
return { score, grade: scoreToGrade(score) }; // A through F
}
// No political pressure. No months of delay.
// Evidence-graded A through F. Shows its work.Every spending category gets a Welfare Evidence Score based on study quality, precision, and recency. Grade A means strong causal evidence of welfare impact. Grade F means no demonstrated benefit. The algorithm scores in milliseconds and can't be lobbied.
The money is small. The real savings: bills scored in milliseconds instead of months, evidence-graded instead of politically pressured, and every citizen can verify the methodology.
“275 humans spend months guessing what a bill will cost. The algorithm does it in 200 milliseconds and shows its work. But sure, let the humans keep guessing.”
— Wishonia
Every Earth agency has a replacement that runs on code instead of bureaucracy. Fund the campaign. See the full system. Set your priorities.